What's next for Kansas high school students whose story led to principal's ouster

Monday, August 21st, 2017 


Photo by Emily Smith, the Redux adviser

From left to right: Bottom: Maddie Baden, Trina Paul, Kali Poenitske, Gina Matthews, Top: Patrick Sullivan, Connor Balthazor

The six high school students in Pittsburg, Kansas, whose investigative journalism led to the resignation of their newly appointed principal, are still reveling in the wake of an article that swept the nation. 

The teenage journalists from Pittsburg High School’s The Booster Redux have called for Schools Superintendent Destry Brown to take responsibility for his initial support of the principal who claimed to have a degree from Corllins University, which is not an accredited school. Robertson resigned in April, five days after the story was published.

“When we looked it up, the first things that popped up on Google search were the words ‘diploma mill,’ ” said Trina Paul, the former editor of the Redux who graduated this year.

Paul and the other students brought their concerns about Amy Robertson, the principal, to Brown in three separate meetings. 

“He just kind of pushed us off,” said Maddie Baden, another Redux editor and rising senior.

“We told him ‘I don’t think this is a real university and I don’t think she’s telling the truth,’” said Kali Poenitske, a rising senior and editor. “He didn’t necessarily seem to care that much.”

Brown and Robertson both claimed she had received her degree from Corllins before the institution lost accreditation, according to an article by The Morning Sun, a local newspaper in Kansas. 

The Redux staff failed to find a building permit for Corllins University, and Robertson claimed she had attended some classes on campus. Robertson further claimed she had a bachelor of fine arts in theater from the University of Tulsa, but that school has never offered that degree.

“I don’t think we’ve ever hired anyone from Tulsa,” Brown said in an interview with the Workshop. “We don’t know what those transcripts look like. I know what Pittsburg State’s looks like, or Kansas State University or Kansas University.” 

The students pushed for Brown to take more responsibility for his initial support of Robertson and for failing to recognize her questionable credentials. In a May editorial, the students wrote further that the Unified School District 250 Board of Education failed to hold him accountable. 

Brown now said that he’s proud of the students for their tenacious reporting.

“The kids helped us to get that moving along a lot faster,” Brown continued. “The research that the kids did helped us because it gave me leverage to use against her. I was proud of them. They certainly represented our school well, and our district.”

Poenitske knew her paper’s work would put honesty first, but she admits they wanted more, she said.

“A public apology would also have been nice, but that did not really happen from Brown either,” Poenitske said. “I think, mainly, we were wanting more of the community to believe in us.”

The Board of Education vowed to examine its hiring procedures in the wake of the story. The Redux staff met with board members to discuss hiring procedures and Brown’s initial dismissal of the journalists’ discovery. 

In response, the school board hired an independent consultant to investigate its hiring practices. The consultant recommended that the school district consider a wider pool of candidates and require potential employees to produce a teaching or administrative license from their current workplace. 

“One of the questions that school board asked was if we would ever be able to trust him again,” Poenitske said of Brown. “I know all of the parents said we would not be able to trust him. But nothing has been done right now. He is still our superintendent.” 

The story ultimately went viral, attracting widespread attention to the student journalists and their investigative reporting. 

The Washington Post, The New York Times and NPR all covered the Kansas students’ reporting, which scored them a table at the White House Correspondents’ Association Dinner in late April courtesy of HuffPost. 

“It was such an inspiration to be in the room with such distinguished journalists, and to have the opportunity to rub elbows with people who are the best in the journalism field,” Paul said. “It was probably one of the best experiences of my life.”

Not everyone was happy with the article. Although negative reactions from other students and teachers were mostly positive, there was some backlash against their story. 

The Booster Redux staff reached out to the nonprofit Student Press Law Center, which helps student journalists navigate censorship issues, during its reporting. 

The journalists were at first hesitant to go after the story because they feared their school’s response, Poenitske said. SPLC staffers helped quell these fears by reviewing the law with the students and ensuring their were no defamation concerns. 

“We saw the train coming down the tracks but we had no idea the impact it was going to have and how it was going to reverberate around the country,” said Frank LoMonte, SPLC’s outgoing executive director. “The fact that this story was taken so seriously by people in authority, that it led to real change and that it went viral around the country was a wonderful, pleasant surprise.” 

The SPLC is the only legal assistance agency which works exclusively with supporting high school and college journalists, which, according to LoMonte, is more important than ever as mainstream journalism suffers severe job loss. 

“That’s a lot of news that’s going uncovered, and that’s a lot of responsibility and opportunity for students,” LoMonte continued. “There are definitely school districts around the country where a high school student is the only reporter who shows up at the school board meetings on a regular basis. 

To deal with heavy-handed administrators, LoMonte recommends student journalists look to the reporters at Flushing High School in New York. There, the principal prevented the publication of an article that criticized engagement of teachers at the school. The students quickly had The New York Post publish their work instead.

 “Don’t assume that just because you get a ‘no’ from the administrators that there is a brick wall,” LoMonte said.  

The students who got the story are now looking ahead to college or another year at the Redux. 

Paul, who was editor during the Robertson reporting, will attend Swarthmore College this fall. 

She is considering a major in economics and intends to continue journalism on one of Swarthmore’s student publications. She and others said they never considered how much they could do with reporting skills and journalism knowledge. 

Poenitske, who spent the summer volunteering at the Hugh O’Brien Youth Leadership program, is also considering a career in journalism. 

“After the Robertson investigation, we were all kind of like ‘Wow, there’s more to this than what we thought,’ ” Poenitske said. “I’ve thought about [journalism] more on the business side of it, maybe being a journalist but not necessarily in a newsroom.”

The future of these editors is still unwritten, as is the future of further investigations from The Booster Redux. 

The August edition of the newspaper will introduce new faculty members and welcome students back to school — under the direction of a new administrator. 

A press release from the board announced that Phil Bressler began as principal July 1. An independent firm tapped him while USD 250’s hiring methods were undergoing review. 

He has worked in secondary school management for 17 years, most recently as principal of Paola High School. 

The release made no mention of where Bressler attended school. 

Incubating new economic models for journalism.

Latest from iLab

How to cover hate

Even as hate crimes occur with more frequency, newsrooms for the most part tend to treat them as individual problems, not as systemic problems that require better follow-through and focus. 

Truth and lies in the Trump era

Trump’s presidency, and the way it is being reported in the media and perceived by the public, has led me to ask some basic questions — about my profession of journalism; the relative power of truth and lies; and the future of democratic self-government in these United States. Does truth even matter in covering this president? Are he and his proclivity for telling falsehoods the problem, or is he a symptom of a deeper affliction in our political-economic system?


Most Recent Posts

A shortlist of fall media

The autumn news cycle boiled over like some Northwestern river amid a peak salmon run. Here are exceptional examples of storytelling I’ve spent time with in the last few weeks. They pinball and rebound between the most salient topics in media of the moment: extreme wealth, the White House and race.

FRONTLINE, IRW launch new fellowship

The PBS series FRONTLINE and the Investigative Reporting Workshop (IRW) at American University’s School of Communication announce a new journalism fellowship.

Barriers still keep disabled voters from polls

Nearly 28 years since the passing of the American’s with Disabilities Act, some polling places and voting systems still are not accessible.

New site keeps journalists' stories alive

On March 2, 2017, Cecilio Pineda, a Mexican investigative reporter, posted a video about the close tie between a drug cartel leader and a local politician on his Facebook account. Two hours later, he was murdered. Pineda’s investigation, along with ones of two other fallen journalists on drug cartels in Mexico, has been translated into nine languages by Forbidden Stories, a newly launched website, so their work can reach as many people as possible. 

Artists from oppressive regimes caution Western political complacency

Most of the West enjoys freedom of expression and media, but artists from oppressive countries warned an American audience not to take their freedom for granted at an event at the National Press Club recently. Dissidents from Russia, Syria, Iran and other countries said their fight for freedom of expression is inextricably linked to the freedom of others around the world.


Workshop Partners

We publish online and in print, often teaming up with other news organizations. We're working now on a new program with FRONTLINE producers, to air later in the year, and on the "Years of Living Dangerously," a series on climate change that has begun airing on Showtime. A story last year on the use of solitary confinement in immigration detention centers was co-published with The New York Times. Our updates to our long-running BankTracker project, in which you can view the financial health of every bank and credit union in the country, have been published with msnbc.com, now nbcnews.com, and we co-published stories in our What Went Wrong series on the economy with The Philadelphia Inquirer and New America Media. Our graduate students are working as researchers with Washington Post reporters, and our new senior editor is a member of the Post's investigative team. Learn more on our partners page.


Investigating Power update

Investigating Power update

Profiles of notable journalists and their stories of key moments in U.S. history in the last 50 years can be found on the Investigating Power site. See Workshop Executive Editor Charles Lewis' latest video interviews as well as historic footage and timelines. You can also read more about the project and why we documented these groundbreaking examples of original, investigative journalism that helped shape or change public perceptions on key issues of our time, from civil rights to Iraq, here.